Egbert Benson Historical Society of Red Hook
ST. PAUL'S CEMETERY ARCHIVES OF THE EGBERT BENSON HISTORICAL SOCIETY (EBHS)
Red Hook Cemetery History
St. Paul’s Lutheran Cemetery
St. Paul’s Lutheran Cemetery dates to circa 1800. It was begun by a German Reformed congregation, which relocated from Old Rhynbeck (Route 9 and Wey Road) to Red Hook. In 1796, they obtained a five-acre lot on Route 9 (King’s Highway) in Red Hook and built a new church on the site occupied by the present church building. The building they erected was a frame building, but this was replaced with a stone structure in 1834. At that time the church was known as the German Reformed, Zion’s Church.
In 1841 Rev. Nicholas Goertner became the first Lutheran Minister to serve the congregation. Perhaps since he served the sister church, St. Peter’s Evangelical Lutheran in Rhinebeck he was chosen to fill the post for the Reformed Congregation. In 1844, under the pastorate of the Rev. Charles F. Schaffer D.D. the congregation joined the Lutheran Church Synod of New York. The present church building for the congregation now known as St. Paul’s Lutheran Church of Red Hook was built in 1890.
Cemetery records are sketchy regarding organization of the cemetery. The first cemetery records, kept in small notebooks, were often difficult to read. Sales of lots and burials in these lots are noted. One of the early notebooks is 3 ½” x 6’, containing writing in a tiny cramped script.
The cemetery includes graves of some pre-Revolutionary period burials. Perhaps these were re-interments. Many soldiers who served in the American Revolution are buried in St. Paul’s Lutheran Cemetery. Those who recognized by the Daughters of the American Revolution are:
John F. Benner
Peter Benner
Henry Davis
Andrew Drom
Thomas Lewis
Jacob Miller
Peterus Moore
Henry Near
Johannis Smith
George Snider
John Stickles
Anthony Straat
Thobias Van Kuren
William Waldorph
Jacob Whiteman
The cemetery is recognized as a Historical Cemetery by the Chancellor Livingston Chapter, DAR.
Over the years, the cemetery has been enlarged by the acquisition of property on the North and East sides. It has now become the principal burying ground in the town of Red Hook.
Work on this database, listing the location of the lots, their owners and the burials known to have occurred was begun in the year 2000. After his retirement in 2000, Richard Hlavac, a dedicated member of the cemetery committee, began compiling the hand written records into a database on his private computer. At his death, Richard had completed most of the early sections of the cemetery. However, the north sections had not yet been completed.
No description of the work on the database or the abbreviations Richard used was discovered. As far as can be surmised, the following code was used in the Surname column: *A open site, not purchased or usedRichard’s widow, Martha has graciously allowed access to the database records. Although the database is not complete, there is much useful information, which this format makes accessible. As corrections and additional section information becomes available, the information will be added to this database.
A committee will maintain the database through the Egbert Benson Historical Society. A copy will be kept in the archives room of the Society. The Red Hook Cemetery Association also has a printed copy of the database at their South Broadway office.
Contact Patsy Vogel
ST. PAUL'S CEMETERY ARCHIVES OF THE EGBERT BENSON HISTORICAL SOCIETY (EBHS)